[As signalled by me earlier, I’m now posting a series of excerpts from the joint paper by Mark Harvey and me with the above title. The first excerpt was here and the second here. This third excerpt is also from section II of the paper. At the end of the post there’s a link to a full PDF version of ‘Marx’s economy and beyond’; it contains the footnotes omitted from these blogpost excerpts. – NG.]
Marx closes the circle of commodity production and consumption outlined in our earlier diagram with his account of what happens to labour-power when used in production. Again, there are ambiguities and confusions in Marx’s own struggle with conceptualization. For he slips from talking of the basket of commodities necessary for the reproduction of labour-power to talking of that necessary for the reproduction of the existence of labour-power. And by that he seems in places strongly to indicate biological existence. From there the circle is closed in production by a suggestion that physical and mental exhaustion, consumption of labour-power as the using up, in addition to use of, labour-capacity, is what occurs in production. In that respect again, labour-power is likened, as we have earlier seen, to the using up of other commodities in production: raw materials (for example, oil) and machinery. There is an expenditure of ‘vital forces’. The living being is physically and mentally depleted, exhausted, by work and then restored by consumption of food, clothing, housing, heating – and TV, I-phones, MP3s, etc, etc. And this link in the chain is what ties reproduction with consumption of labour-power within a closed commodity circuit. So, however ambiguous and open to interpretation, it is difficult to understate the role of this conception in the theory – it is an indispensable link in the analytical chain.
And of course, there is much that is convincing in Marx’s account, and not to be jettisoned. People do need to eat – even eat well – to live, and thereby to work. But again we come back to the knowledge of the knowledge-bearers, and now to its use in production. It certainly is used, but equally certainly it is not, in the other sense of the word and by contrast with raw materials, used up. The biological brain may become physically tired, but the ideas and knowledge do not. There is a strong argument, indeed, that knowledge and skills are enhanced, even developed in use, and (again) collectively. Undoubtedly, such knowledge enhancement or development, knowledge outputs, may well be appropriated by the employers of the bearers of knowledge, through intellectual property rights. But the difficulties of employers in ensuring the kind of property rights over this knowledge that they typically have over other outputs, given that it also resides in the knowledge-bearers, are also well known. And, to conclude this point concerning the use of labour-power in production, if knowledge is used, but not used up, in production, it is not in need of restoration, and certainly not by the consumption of anything one might like to put in a basket of commodities. So, this final link in the chain of a labour-theory-of-value understanding of surplus value production is also broken, in a way calling for further development of the analysis of economies of labour.
[I shall be posting further excerpts later this week. For the full paper (PDF), ‘Marx’s economy and beyond‘, click through the link. See also ‘On working together‘.]